Rules for Write-icles: The Hallmark of the Second-Rater
This is why I don’t review books on Good Reads.
About 10 years ago, an acquaintance of mine got me to read Atlas Shrugged, by Ayn Rand. As a person with rampant ADHD I tend to shy away from enormous books, but I got it on audio and listened to it. I quite liked it, but that’s not the point. Something one of her characters said resonated so loudly, that despite having the attention span of a cocker spaniel, I’ve never forgotten it. The character said that to be envious of the achievements of others is the hallmark of the second-rater.
It’s very easy to look at the works of others and think; “Wow, they got lucky.” It’s easy to read a book and tear it apart. Maybe you think you could do better. Maybe you could. But your opinion, however valid, doesn’t dim the achievement of whomever wrote it. I know lots of people who profess to loathe Dan Brown or Stephanie Meyer but would sell their firstborn for even half of that success. Brown, Meyer and others are successful because they did what authors have to do to succeed, sell books. You can be a NYT or Amazon bestseller without writing a good book. You can do it without having well rounded, deep characters, and you can do it without deep thematic meaning. All you have to do is sell books. That’s the author’s job. And if you can do that, the other things don’t much matter.
Tearing down someone’s work, especially when you don’t like it, is easy and it’s fun. It doesn’t take any particular skill to have a negative opinion and express it, but that’s second rater thinking. Far too many authors sit around an bemoan their lack of success. They pontificate on the inexplicable success of other authors who have written bad books. It’s easy to do, I’ve done it myself. And every time I do I have to stop and remind myself that I’m thinking about it all wrong. That complaining about another’s success is second-rater thinking. The real lesson in the success of a bad book is that if it can succeed, so can my books.
That’s why I don’t review books on Good Reads.
Comparing yourself to other writers is the single most destructive thing an author can do. It erodes your self-confidence and gives rise to doubts. Doubts about everything from your style to your characters to your fundamental storytelling. It leads to the paralysis of analysis. That’s where an author sits around for years “intending” to write a book, but never puts a singe word down. It’s death for a creative person.
I’m under no illusions, I’m a C-List writer. But I have no intention of staying there. If I ever want to be more, I’ve got to learn to do what those successful authors do. I have to learn to sell books. The only way to sell books is to write them first. The first-rater never lets the success or failure of others get in the way of their own success. They take responsibility for being successful themselves.
Give someone a book, and they’ll read for a day. Teach someone to write a book, and they’ll spend a lifetime mired in paralyzing self doubt.
Had a great surprise waiting for me on my porch when I got home from my morning meeting. Thanks to modern, real time, delivery tracking and my smartphone, it wasn’t really a surprise, but I was still excited. I spent months tracking down this thing and, after a lucky...
So, I just watched the pilot episode of Fox’s new Sci-Fi show, The Orville, and I quite liked it. To answer the immediate and obvious questions, yes, it is a blatant rip-off of the most successful Star Trek series to date: Star Trek: the Next Generation. Second,...
Had a great surprise waiting for me on my porch when I got home from my morning meeting. Thanks to modern, real time, delivery tracking and my smartphone, it wasn’t really a surprise, but I was still excited. I spent months tracking down this thing and, after a...
Anyone who knows me knows that I am quite the Apple fan. I’ve been a Mac user for so long that I actually owned a Lisa. (Look it up.) I’m no fanboy, I don’t have a shrine to Steve Jobs in my basement, or anything, but I sure do love what Apple does. I also won’t tell you to “get a Mac” when you express problems with your PC. I’m happy to let you do your thing the way you want and I expec the same courtesy.
SUBSCRIBE TO THE NEWSLETTER